FIRST MID BANCSHARES INC (FMBH)
Sector: Financials
2026 Annual Meeting Analysis
FIRST MID BANCSHARES INC · Meeting: April 29, 2026
Directors FOR
4
Directors AGAINST
0
Say on Pay
FOR
Auditor
FOR
Director Elections
Election of Directors
McCurry has served since February 2021 (just over 5 years), brings relevant banking and legal expertise, attended all required meetings, holds no disqualifying outside board seats, and FMBH's 3-year stock return of +64.4% outperformed the community bank peer median (+44.4%) by +20pp — well below the 65pp trigger threshold for strong-positive-TSR companies.
Melvin joined the board in November 2025 — less than 24 months ago — and is therefore fully exempt from the TSR performance trigger under policy; he brings relevant retail operations and real estate expertise and no other disqualifying flags apply.
Palmby joined in November 2024 (approximately 17 months ago), placing him within the 24-month new-director exemption from the TSR trigger; he brings executive leadership, M&A, and prior community bank board experience (Blackhawk Bancorp), and no other disqualifying flags apply.
Westerhold has served since 2016, is the designated audit committee financial expert, attended all required meetings, holds no excess outside board seats, and FMBH's strong 3-year outperformance of peers (+20pp) does not trigger the TSR threshold of 65pp applicable to companies with strong positive absolute returns.
All four Class I nominees pass policy screens: FMBH's 3-year total shareholder return of +64.4% outperformed the disclosed compensation peer median by +20pp, well below the 65pp trigger threshold applicable to companies with strong positive absolute TSR. No overboarding, attendance, independence, or familial-relationship concerns were identified. Two nominees (Melvin, Palmby) are exempt from the TSR trigger due to tenure under 24 months. The board discloses a skills matrix and has a qualified audit committee financial expert. All four nominees are recommended FOR.
Say on Pay
✓ FORCEO
Joseph R. Dively
Total Comp
$2,109,337
Prior Support
97%%
CEO Joseph Dively's total reported compensation of $2,109,337 is reasonable for a CEO of a $1 billion regional community bank, and the prior say-on-pay vote received overwhelming 97% shareholder support in 2023, signaling broad satisfaction with the program. Pay mix is appropriately weighted toward variable pay — base salary of $543,400 represents roughly 26% of total compensation, with the remainder in performance-tied cash bonuses and stock awards, well within the policy's requirement that fixed pay not exceed 40% of total. The incentive plan uses multiple quantifiable metrics (net income, asset quality, efficiency ratio, lines of business, and loan growth), performance exceeded targets in 2025, and the company maintains a meaningful clawback policy covering both restatements and executive misconduct.
Auditor Ratification
✓ FORAuditor
Forvis Mazars, LLP
Tenure
20 yrs
Audit Fees
$622,250
Non-Audit Fees
$64,603
Non-audit fees (audit-related fees of $45,903 plus other fees of $18,700, totaling $64,603) represent approximately 10% of audit fees of $622,250 — well below the 50% threshold that would raise independence concerns. Forvis Mazars has served since July 2005 (approximately 20 years), which is below the 25-year tenure trigger. No material financial restatements were disclosed. While Forvis Mazars is not a Big 4 firm, it is a large national firm considered adequate for a $1 billion community bank. All services were pre-approved by the audit committee.
Overall Assessment
The 2026 First Mid Bancshares annual meeting ballot contains two management proposals — director elections and an advisory say-on-pay vote — with no auditor ratification proposal formally listed on the ballot (the proxy discloses auditor fee information but states the company has not yet formally appointed its 2026 auditor). All four director nominees pass policy screens given FMBH's strong 3-year stock performance relative to peers, and the executive compensation program earns a FOR vote based on its well-structured, heavily performance-weighted design and strong prior shareholder support of 97%.
Compensation Peer Group
16 companies disclosed in 2026 proxy filing